The Moveee team
Free coaching · a real route for every ride
Creatine has the reputation of a gym supplement — something for people who care about bench press, not about W/kg. That reputation is out of date, but the scepticism behind it is not entirely misplaced. Creatine does something real, and it is one of the few supplements with genuinely strong evidence behind it. The catch for cyclists is that it also makes you heavier.
So the honest question is not "does creatine work" — it does — but does what it does outweigh the extra kilo or so you carry up every climb? The answer depends almost entirely on what kind of riding you do.
This article summarises published research on a dietary supplement. It is not a recommendation that you take it. If you have kidney or liver problems, take prescription medication, are pregnant, or are under 18, talk to a doctor before supplementing anything. Competitive riders should also check that any product they buy is batch-tested — contamination, not creatine itself, is the doping risk.
What creatine actually does
Your muscles hold a small store of phosphocreatine, which exists to regenerate ATP — the molecule your muscle fibres actually spend — very quickly. It is the fuel system that covers the first few seconds of any maximal effort, before glycolysis and then aerobic metabolism take over. It is also the system that has to be rebuilt between efforts.
Supplementing creatine raises the amount of creatine stored in muscle by roughly 20% in people who are not already saturated. That larger store means slightly more work available at very high intensity, and — probably more usefully for a cyclist — faster restoration of that store between repeated efforts. Vegetarians and vegans typically start from lower stores and tend to respond more. Some people, perhaps one in five, barely respond at all.
Where the benefit is, by effort duration
This is the part most write-ups skip. Creatine's benefit is not general — it is concentrated at one end of the duration spectrum and disappears completely at the other.
Under 30 seconds
Best evidenceA sprint, a kick for the sign, a steep 20-second ramp
This is where the phosphocreatine system is doing most of the work, and where meta-analysis finds the clearest benefit.
Repeated short efforts
Good evidenceCrit attacks, a punchy circuit, on-off racing
The gain is partly in recovery between efforts — more phosphocreatine to resynthesise, faster, so the fifth attack costs less than it used to.
1–5 minutes
MixedA short climb, a bridging effort, a pursuit
Some studies show a small benefit, many show none. Treat any gain here as a bonus, not the reason to take it.
Steady efforts over ~10 minutes
No direct benefitA long climb, a time trial, a tempo block
Aerobic work is not limited by phosphocreatine. Creatine does nothing for it — and the added mass works against you uphill.
The bars are a visual summary of the direction and consistency of the published evidence, not a measured percentage gain. Individual response varies a great deal.
The weight problem, with numbers
Creatine draws water into muscle cells. The typical result is around 1 to 2 kg of gain in the first week or two of a loading protocol — more with a fast load, less with a slow one. This is intracellular water, not bloating in any meaningful sense, and it is not fat. But gravity does not care where the mass is.
| Mass | Power | Ratio | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Before | 70.0 kg | 300 W | 4.29 W/kg |
| After ~1.2 kg of water weight | 71.2 kg | 300 W | 4.21 W/kg |
Roughly a 1.7% drop in climbing W/kg — on a steady 30-minute climb, in the region of half a minute. A rough illustration, not a measurement: real climbing speed also depends on gradient, drag and pacing.
Half a minute is not nothing, but nor is it a catastrophe. The point is the trade: you are exchanging a small, permanent uphill tax for a benefit that only pays out in short, sharp efforts. If your season is hill climbs and long alpine sportives, that is a bad trade. If it is crits, cyclocross, track, or road racing that gets decided by attacks, it is a defensible one.
There is a useful nuance here. One well-controlled study of trained cyclists found that creatine did not improve overall 120 km time-trial performance — but power in the closing sprints, late in a long and depleting ride, was higher. That is a narrow benefit, and it is worth being honest that it is narrow.
Loading, or just taking it
The classic protocol comes from work in the 1990s that measured muscle creatine directly. Two routes reach the same saturation point:
Fast load
~20 g/day, split into 4 doses, for 5–7 days — then 2–5 g/day
Muscle stores near-full in about a week
The quickest route, and the one most likely to cause stomach upset and a visible jump on the scales.
Slow load
3 g/day, no loading phase
Same end point, reached over roughly 28 days
Gentler on the gut, weight gain arrives gradually. If you are not in a hurry, this is the sensible default.
A few practical points:
- Creatine monohydrate is the form to use. It is the one that has been studied to exhaustion, and it is the cheapest. The exotic variants sold at a premium have not shown themselves to be better.
- Timing barely matters. Saturation is about total daily intake over weeks, not about hitting a window. Take it whenever you will remember.
- It is not a taper supplement. If you are going to try it, do it in an off-season or base block — not in the fortnight before a goal event, when you do not want a novel gut experiment or a sudden 1.5 kg.
- Stopping is easy. Stores drift back to baseline over several weeks, and the water goes with them.
Is it safe?
Creatine monohydrate is among the most heavily studied supplements in existence, and the safety record in healthy adults is good — including in trials running for months to years. The persistent claim that it damages healthy kidneys is not supported by the evidence; the confusion largely comes from creatine raising blood creatinine, a marker used to estimate kidney function, without kidney function actually changing. That is worth mentioning to your doctor before a blood test, so nobody misreads the result.
The IOC's consensus statement on supplements lists creatine among the small handful with sufficient evidence to be considered for performance, alongside caffeine, nitrate, beta-alanine and bicarbonate. That is about as strong an endorsement as this category gets, and it still comes with the caveat about third-party testing.
The realistic downsides are mundane: gastrointestinal discomfort during a fast load, and the weight.
So: yes or no?
- Probably worth it if you race criteriums, cyclocross, track, or road events decided by repeated attacks — and if you also lift, which most riders should.
- Probably not worth it if you are a climber, a long-distance time triallist, or someone chasing a sportive up a mountain. You would be paying a W/kg tax for a benefit you rarely use.
- Irrelevant if your training, sleep or fuelling are not yet in order. Creatine is a rounding error next to those. The riders who gain most from a supplement are the ones who have already run out of bigger things to fix.
If you do want to see the trade-off in your own numbers rather than in an illustrative table, that is what a Moveee power profile is for: it estimates your FTP and your short-duration power from your actual rides, so a month on creatine shows up as a change in both absolute watts and W/kg, rather than as a feeling. If your five-second power rises and your 20-minute W/kg quietly falls, you have your answer.
Sources 7
Where this article summarises a study, the study itself is linked — not a write-up of it.
- 1 Kreider RB, Kalman DS, Antonio J, et al. International Society of Sports Nutrition position stand: safety and efficacy of creatine supplementation in exercise, sport, and medicine · Journal of the International Society of Sports Nutrition · 2017
- 2 Hultman E, Söderlund K, Timmons JA, et al. Muscle creatine loading in men · Journal of Applied Physiology · 1996
- 3 Branch JD Effect of creatine supplementation on body composition and performance: a meta-analysis · International Journal of Sport Nutrition and Exercise Metabolism · 2003
- 4 Tomcik KA, Camera DM, Bone JL, et al. Effects of creatine and carbohydrate loading on cycling time trial performance · Medicine & Science in Sports & Exercise · 2018
- 5 Powers ME, Arnold BL, Weltman AL, et al. Creatine supplementation increases total body water without altering fluid distribution · Journal of Athletic Training · 2003
- 6 Antonio J, Candow DG, Forbes SC, et al. Common questions and misconceptions about creatine supplementation: what does the scientific evidence really show? · Journal of the International Society of Sports Nutrition · 2021
- 7 Maughan RJ, Burke LM, Dvorak J, et al. IOC consensus statement: dietary supplements and the high-performance athlete · British Journal of Sports Medicine · 2018
A plan that knows how long tomorrow is
Moveee builds your week from your own rides and keeps it honest about duration and intensity — which is the number every fuelling decision on this page depends on. Free coaching, and it adapts when life gets in the way.
See your planKeep reading
Hydration in the heat: sodium, ice and the pre-cool
Heat costs watts whatever you drink. What helps: starting cool with ice slurry, keeping body-mass loss under about 2%, matching sodium to how salty you sweat, and not drinking past thirst.
Omega-3 for cyclists: what it does, what it doesn't
A supplement with a plausible mechanism, a decent safety record and a thin performance record. What EPA and DHA appear to do for muscle and recovery, what the direct performance trials show, and the dose that is actually studied.
The refuelling window: how real is it, and when does it matter?
The thirty-minute window is real, quite small, and almost irrelevant unless you are riding again tomorrow morning. What the research actually supports, the dose per kilogram, and the specific situations where the clock genuinely matters.
Caffeine for cyclists: how much, how long before, and the catch
Caffeine is one of the few supplements with genuinely strong evidence behind it. The effective dose, when to take it, why habitual coffee drinkers still respond — and what it costs your sleep if you time it badly.
Do you need protein after every ride? What the evidence says
The thirty-minute anabolic window turned out to be far wider than anyone thought. What the research says about per-meal dose, daily totals and whether an endurance rider needs a shake after every easy spin.
Iron and ferritin for cyclists: the blood test worth asking for
Low iron is one of the more common causes of unexplained fatigue in endurance athletes, and one of the few that is genuinely fixable. Why "your bloods are normal" can still mean you are short — and why you must never supplement on a hunch.
You dehydrate in winter too
Dehydration is a summer problem — that assumption sits behind almost every winter ride and it is wrong. Five reasons riders run short in the cold, what it costs, and the one change that fixes most of it.
Carb loading before a gran fondo: how to do it properly
The old depletion-week protocol is long dead. What a modern one- to two-day carb load looks like, how many grams per kilo you're actually aiming for, and why the scale goes up before a good ride.
Electrolytes explained: sodium, cramp and what actually helps
Sweat sodium losses vary enormously between riders, and the popular explanation for cramp may be the wrong one entirely. What electrolytes do, what the cramp research says, and the risk of drinking too much.
Drinking too much: hyponatraemia and why more water isn't safer
It looks like dehydration, it is treated the opposite way, and drinking more makes it worse. Who exercise-associated hyponatraemia actually happens to, why salt tablets are not the answer, and the symptoms that mean call for help now.
Fuelling on a budget: cheap carbs that work on the bike
Bananas, raisins, jam sandwiches and potatoes have been tested against gels and sports drinks and fuel a ride just as well. The grams per pocket portion, what they cost, and where they fall short.
Choosing safer roads: what the crash data says about route planning
Riders fear being hit from behind; the collision statistics are dominated by junctions and turning vehicles. What the research says about where risk actually concentrates, and how to turn that into a route-planning habit rather than a worry.