Why riding indoors feels harder: what the research actually says
The Moveee team
Free coaching · a real route for every ride
You know the feeling. The same 2×20 that goes fine on your local climb turns into a fight on the trainer, and the numbers you see in the garage are a little lower than the ones you see in summer. Is that real, or is it in your head?
It's mostly real, it's usually smaller than it feels, and it's very personal. We went through the published studies while working out how Moveee Indoor should set indoor targets. Here's what they actually say, without the forum folklore.
What the studies measured
Only a handful of studies compare the same riders, with the same power meter, inside and out. They don't all agree, and the differences between them tell you as much as the numbers do.
| Study | Who and what | Indoors vs outdoors |
|---|---|---|
| Lipski et al. 2022 | 14 pro and Continental riders, 1–14 min max efforts | Lower indoors at every duration, about 4–9 %. Critical power 19 W lower. Big rider-to-rider spread. |
| Jeffries et al. 2019 | 20 competitive riders, 20 min time trial | 280 W indoors vs 284 W outside, a 1.4 % gap that wasn't significant. |
| Smith et al. 2001 | 8 trained riders, 40 km time trial | 303 W vs 312 W, about 3 % lower indoors, also not significant. |
| Mieras et al. 2014 | 12 recreational riders, 40 km at the same perceived effort | 163 W indoors vs 208 W outside, 22 % lower. Skin 1.6 °C warmer indoors, no airflow. |
| Olsson et al. 2024 | 20 commuters, matched intensity and matched effort | At the same perceived effort they rode 19–30 % harder outdoors. |
Put together, a pattern appears:
- Trained riders doing all-out tests in decent conditions lose roughly 0–9 % indoors, most often 3–6 %. Two of the three time-trial studies found a gap too small to be sure it was real.
- Riders going by feel, with no fan, can lose 20–30 %. That's what Mieras and Olsson found. When nobody tells you a number, you simply ease off indoors.
- Not everyone is slower indoors. Lipski's pros varied a lot from rider to rider, and a few did as well or better on the trainer. An average is a starting point, not your number.
Honestly: thin. These are small studies, 8 to 20 riders each, with different tests and different rooms. They agree that a gap usually exists and that heat drives most of it. They don't support one exact percentage for everybody. Treat any default figure, including ours, as a reasonable first guess that your own rides should correct.
The causes, ranked by evidence
Cooling and airflow
StrongOutside you ride in your own wind. Indoors the heat stays on your skin, heart rate drifts up and power drops. Every study that changed airflow found a difference.
Pacing, motivation, boredom
ModerateWith nothing to chase, riders pace by feel and back off. A rival on screen or a real road ahead adds a few per cent.
Two different power meters
ModerateYour trainer and your crank meter can disagree by a few per cent. Many "indoor gaps" are partly just two instruments.
Terrain
ModerateMost riders hold more power uphill than on the flat. An FTP set on a climb won't fully carry over to a flat trainer.
Cadence and flywheel feel
WeakRiders spin about 6 rpm faster indoors, partly because the trainer's flywheel feels lighter than a moving bike.
A bike that doesn't move
Weak or noneNo good evidence that a fixed bike costs power. Rocker plates help comfort, not watts.
Heat is the big one
Riding at 200 W, your body makes several times that much heat. Outside, the wind you make by moving carries it off as sweat evaporates. Indoors, without real airflow, your skin warms, more blood goes to the skin to cool you, heart rate climbs and the power you can hold drops. Mieras measured skin 1.6 °C warmer in the lab with no wind, against 2.5 m/s of airflow outside.
Two studies show how much airflow is worth. In a 15 km time trial in the heat, adding wind lifted power from 246 to 256 W and saved over a minute (Teunissen et al.). And in a normal-temperature room, a fan let riders hold 15 % more work at the same heart rate, with no change in how hard it felt (Fernandez et al.). We cover what that means for your setup in fans, room temperature and power matching.
Your head counts too
Olsson's commuters rated the same intensity as easier outdoors, by 1.4 to 2.7 points on the effort scale. Studies on pacing show that having someone to race lifts time-trial performance by itself. A wall gives you nothing to chase. A road, a rival or a clear target on screen does.
Sometimes it's the meter, not you
If you ride a crank meter outside and trust the trainer's number inside, part of your "gap" can be two instruments that don't agree. Rule that out before blaming your legs. Our guide to smart trainer power accuracy goes into how far they drift.
What doesn't matter much
No coasting changes how tiring an hour is, not how much power you can hold at threshold; that's a training-load question, covered in is an hour indoors worth 90 minutes outside?. The slightly faster cadence indoors is real but small. And there's no good evidence that a bike that can't sway costs you watts.
What to do with this
- Fix cooling first. A strong fan and a cool room close most of the gap for most riders. It's the only cause with strong evidence, and it's the cheapest fix.
- Check your power source. Compare trainer and power meter on the same ride before deciding anything about fitness.
- Then, if a gap remains, set your indoor targets a little lower, by your own amount, not a forum figure. The old advice in why your indoor FTP is lower still holds: train to the number you can hold where you train. In Moveee that number is your Indoor FTP, and your indoor sessions adapt to it once you confirm.
- Don't read the gap as lost fitness. A few per cent lower in a warm room in January is physics, not decline.
The useful bit is your own data. In Moveee, every trainer session saves with full power and sits next to your outdoor rides, so you can see your own gap instead of guessing it.
Sources 9
Where this article summarises a study, the study itself is linked — not a write-up of it.
- 1 Lipski ES, Spindler DJ, Hesselink MKC, Myers TD, Sanders D Differences in performance assessments conducted indoors and outdoors in professional cyclists · International Journal of Sports Physiology and Performance · 2022
- 2 Jeffries O, Waldron M, Patterson SD, Galna B An analysis of variability in power output during indoor and outdoor cycling time trials · International Journal of Sports Physiology and Performance · 2019
- 3 Smith MF, Davison RC, Balmer J, Bird SR Reliability of mean power recorded during indoor and outdoor self-paced 40 km cycling time-trials · International Journal of Sports Medicine · 2001
- 4 Mieras ME, Heesch MWS, Slivka DR Physiological and psychological responses to outdoor vs. laboratory cycling · Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research · 2014
- 5 Olsson KSE, Ceci R, Wahlgren L, Rosdahl H, Schantz P Perceived exertion can be lower when exercising in field versus indoors · PLoS One · 2024
- 6 Teunissen LP, de Haan A, de Koning JJ, Daanen HA Effects of wind application on thermal perception and self-paced performance · European Journal of Applied Physiology · 2013
- 7 Fernandez A, Wimer GS, Culver MN, Flatt AA, Grosicki GJ Fan cooling improves submaximal exercise capacity in an indoor thermoneutral environment · Research Quarterly for Exercise and Sport · 2023
- 8 Williams EL, Jones HS, Sparks SA, Marchant DC, Midgley AW, McNaughton LR Competitor presence reduces internal attentional focus and improves 16.1 km cycling time trial performance · Journal of Science and Medicine in Sport · 2015
- 9 Hovorka M, Leo P, Simon D, Prinz B, Nimmerichter A Effects of flat and uphill cycling on the power-duration relationship · International Journal of Sports Medicine · 2022
Your own roads, indoors, in a browser tab
Moveee Indoor pairs your smart trainer over Bluetooth and rebuilds a route you have saved as a 3D road — real gradients, ERG for the intervals, and the ride saved with full power data. Nothing to install. Free while it is in alpha.
Start an indoor rideKeep reading
Menstrual cycle and cycling training: what the research actually shows
Phase-based training plans are sold with far more confidence than the evidence supports. An honest read of a genuinely weak literature — and the things that are well established, from iron status to energy availability.
Big-gear, low-cadence work: strength on the bike, or just slow?
Fifty rpm up a climb in a gear you can barely turn feels like it must be building something. What torque intervals actually train, what the evidence says about transfer to real power, and the knee-load caution nobody puts in the session description.
Do long slow rides still work? The evidence for volume
Intervals get the attention, but the adaptations that make a cyclist durable come mostly from time. What the research says about volume, why low intensity isn't wasted time, and how short a long ride can usefully be.
Three zones, five or seven? Which model to actually use
Open three training books and you get three zone systems. They are not competing discoveries about the body — they are filing systems, and you want more than one. Which to use for the week, the session and the top end.
Your FTP went down. Six reasons, and only one of them is fitness
Same trainer, same test, twelve watts lower. Before you rewrite the plan: a lower test result usually is not lost fitness. The six causes in order of how often they turn out to be the answer, and the five-minute check that tells you which.
Cycling cadence: does it actually matter? What the science says
The internet is full of one true cadence — the research says your legs already found theirs. What the science honestly shows about self-selected cadence, when deliberate high or low RPM work genuinely helps, the typical ranges by situation, and the drills worth folding into an easy hour.
How to pace a climb with power (and stop blowing up halfway)
Everyone goes out too hard on the big climb. Here's how to use power (or feel) to pace a climb from bottom to top so you finish strong instead of cracking.
Why your indoor FTP is lower (and what to do about it)
Most riders push noticeably less power indoors than out. Heat is the main culprit — here's the physiology, how big the gap usually is, and how to close most of it.

Is an hour indoors worth 90 minutes outside? Indoor vs outdoor training load
The 1:1.5 rule is folklore. What no coasting really changes, why kJ and TSS compare better than hours, and how to replace a long outdoor ride on the trainer without dreading it.
Fitness, Fatigue and Form: reading your training load without overthinking it
Three numbers explain almost everything about your training — whether you're building, digging a hole, or ready to fly. Here's how Fitness, Fatigue and Form work, in plain English.
Morning or evening: does the time you train change what you get?
Peak power really is higher in the late afternoon, and the effect is much smaller than the effect of actually doing the session. What circadian rhythm does to performance, and why the honest answer is "whenever you will keep turning up".
How to wash a bike without wrecking it
There are two or three ways to clean a bike that cause more damage than the dirt would have — and they are the ones that feel most satisfying. Fifteen minutes, in the right order, without contaminating your brakes.